by Matt Bromley
Alan Milburn’s final report into the NEETs crisis – From a Welfare State to a Working State – is an ambitious attempt to understand why so many young people are becoming detached from education, employment, and training, and what needs to change to prevent this happening.
The scale of the challenge is considerable:
• 981,000 young people aged 16–24 are classified as NEET – that’s 1 in 8.
• Of those who are NEET, 6 in 10 have never worked.
The report describes a situation that’s developed over decades, not one that’s a temporary consequence of economic uncertainty or a difficult labour market.
Milburn argues that the UK has created a system which is too often reactive, fragmented, and focused on dealing with failure after it has happened.
His diagnosis is that five systems are failing to work together:
- Education: Too many young people leave school without the qualifications, skills, confidence or experience they need.
- Employment: There are insufficient opportunities for young people to access their first job and begin a career.
- Health: Mental and physical health needs are identified too late, with support often difficult to access.
- Welfare: The system can inadvertently sustain economic inactivity rather than provide a route towards participation.
- Public services: Responsibility is fragmented between schools, colleges, local authorities, employers, health services and government departments.
Crucially, Milburn is not claiming that schools alone are responsible for the NEET problem; rather, he’s arguing that schools are an essential part of a system which currently fails to join up.
As such, it would be misguided to interpret the report as an instruction for schools to solve unemployment, poverty, mental illness, and social inequality simply through better careers education. But, equally, it would be wrong for schools to assume that the problem begins when a young person leaves the school gates. The seeds of disengagement are often visible much earlier.
So, what can schools do to help solve the NEETs crisis?
To answer that, it’s important to first understand the roots of the problem…
Why do young people become NEET?
The report identifies a number of risk factors, many of which are visible during a young person’s school career.
Disengagement begins earlier than we think
Schools often know which young people are at risk of becoming NEET long before they reach 16.
The report identifies:
• Persistent absence.
• Low attainment, particularly in English and mathematics.
• Suspension and exclusion.
• Special educational needs and disabilities.
• Experience of being in care.
• Disadvantage and poverty.
• Poor mental health.
• Weak relationships with school and a lack of belonging.
One particularly striking finding is that persistent absentees in a Bradford study were almost four times more likely to become NEET between the ages of 16 and 18.
The report also highlights that only 70% of 15-year-olds in the UK report feeling that they belong at school – and if a young person does not feel that school is a place where they belong, if they regularly miss lessons, if they are falling behind academically, and if their relationship with education is increasingly negative, then the risk of future disengagement grows. The report argues that these indicators should be considered together, rather than treated as separate issues belonging to different departments.
Our curriculum does not prepare everyone adequately for working life
Milburn is critical of a system which has become too focused on examination outcomes. His argument is not that academic standards should be lowered – in fact, he explicitly supports maintaining high standards – rather, he questions whether qualifications alone are sufficient preparation for adult life.
The report presents some revealing survey findings:
- NEET young people who believe the curriculum does not prepare them for work = 67%
- NEET young people who feel the education system does not suit people like them = 55%
- Teachers who believe there is too much emphasis on passing exams = 74%
- Teachers who believe there is insufficient focus on work preparation = 73%
Employers, meanwhile, report that young people often lack work experience, confidence, maturity, and an understanding of workplace expectations.
Milburn’s contention is that schools have become very good at producing qualifications, but less consistent at producing young people who are ready to use those qualifications in the world beyond education.
Careers education comes too late
The report is particularly critical of the lack of meaningful careers education and employer engagement. Milburn says that too many young people make decisions about their futures without having a proper understanding of the opportunities available. The problem is compounded by the fact that access to opportunities is often determined by family connections. A student whose parents have professional networks may find it relatively easy to secure a meaningful work placement. Another student, with equally strong potential but fewer connections, may have much more limited access. This creates a social mobility problem.
Milburn argues that social capital – the networks, relationships, and knowledge that help people access opportunities – should not be left to chance or inherited through family circumstances; schools should help provide it.
The transition at 16 is too fragile
For some young people, leaving school is the point at which everything begins to unravel.
They may:
• Fail to secure their preferred college place.
• Start a course which turns out to be unsuitable.
• Struggle with the transition to a larger, less familiar environment.
• Lose the pastoral relationships they had at school.
• Find that their mental health difficulties become more difficult to manage.
• Lack the confidence or practical support to navigate employment or further education.
The report highlights that some young people leave school, college, or training early, but no one takes clear responsibility for what happens next. The institution records the departure. The young person becomes someone else’s responsibility. Or, sometimes, nobody’s responsibility. This is one of the central problems Milburn wants to address.
Further education is not being used to its full potential
Milburn believes FE colleges should become the principal technical and transition institutions in England. He argues that the UK has underinvested in technical education and vocational learning, particularly for young adults aged 18–24. The result is a comparatively weak pathway between education and skilled employment.
He wants colleges to become much more central to:
• Technical education.
• Pre-apprenticeship provision.
• Apprenticeships.
• Employer-led training.
• Re-engagement of young people who have dropped out of education or employment.
• Higher technical qualifications at Levels 4 and 5.
This is a substantial change in the role he envisages for FE. It is not simply about offering more courses; it’s about positioning colleges as a central part of the infrastructure which moves young people into sustained employment.

What can we do about it?
Here are 7 suggestions for schools based on Milburn’s report…
1. Identify risk earlier – and intervene before disengagement becomes entrenched
Milburn proposes that both primary and secondary schools should be required to use data more systematically to identify pupils at risk of becoming NEET. He specifically advocates the mandatory use of risk indicators, building on existing approaches such as RONI (Risk of NEET Indicator).
Schools should consider information collectively, including:
- Attendance.
- Attainment.
- SEND.
- Care experience.
- Suspensions and exclusions.
- Pastoral information.
- School readiness and early developmental history.
No single indicator should determine a pupil’s future. A student with SEND is not automatically at risk of becoming NEET. Nor is a student with poor attendance necessarily destined to disengage. However, when several indicators begin to converge, schools should recognise the potential significance.
What this means for schools:
> Move from a reactive pastoral model to a predictive and preventative model.
> Rather than waiting for a student to become persistently absent, disengaged or excluded, identify patterns early and coordinate support.
2. Reconsider the Key Stage 3 curriculum
Milburn argues that Key Stage 3 is frequently neglected because resources and intervention become concentrated around GCSE performance.
He proposes:
- A statutory Key Stage 3 writing, numeracy and oracy check.
- More flexibility for schools to respond to pupils’ interests and aptitudes.
- 10% of the Key Stage 3 timetable to sit outside the national curriculum.
- A proportionate reduction in the national curriculum to make this possible.
The proposed 10% flexibility could be used for:
- Additional English and mathematics support.
- Academic extension.
- Science and technology.
- Music, drama and the arts.
- Sport and outdoor education.
- Technical exploration.
- Enterprise.
- Employer-led projects.
- Activities which help pupils discover their interests and strengths.
This is not intended to create a lower-status curriculum for less academic students. Quite the opposite: Milburn argues that this flexibility should be available to all pupils.
What this means for schools:
> Key Stage 3 should become a deliberate period of exploration, engagement and preparation, not simply a waiting room for GCSEs.
3. Give technical education greater parity with academic education
Milburn supports the introduction of Vocational GCSEs alongside more established academic qualifications. He wants technical education to become a core part of school provision, rather than an alternative for students who are perceived to be less academically capable.
He also proposes greater collaboration between:
- Schools.
- Multi-academy trusts.
- FE colleges.
- University Technical Colleges.
- Specialist providers.
- Employers.
This would allow schools to share expensive facilities, specialist teachers, and employer relationships. The ambition is to create a broad curriculum in which academic and technical learning are complementary.
What this means for schools:
> Review whether curriculum pathways genuinely offer students choice and whether technical education is valued as highly as academic education.
> Schools should also consider whether partnerships with FE colleges and other local providers could expand the range and quality of their offer.
4. Make work experience a statutory entitlement
Milburn wants every young person to have access to high-quality workplace experience. He proposes making work experience a statutory duty on schools. Importantly, he does not envisage this as a single two-week placement at the end of Year 10. Instead, he wants a cumulative programme of employer exposure throughout the school journey.
His suggested approach is:
| Age/stage | Proposed experience |
| Primary | Encounters with employers; broadening horizons and challenging stereotypes |
| Key Stage 3 | Workplace visits, employer projects, talks, enterprise activities and FE/apprenticeship tasters |
| Key Stage 4 | Meaningful experience in a real workplace, normally including a substantial placement |
| Post-16 technical education | Structured workplace experience proportionate to the course |
He also wants access to placements to be independent of parental contacts. Schools should work with local employer networks and careers infrastructure to broker opportunities.
What this means for schools:
> Work experience needs to become a planned, progressive element of the curriculum.
> It should be designed, quality-assured, and evaluated in the same way as other important aspects of provision.
5. Develop a clear definition of work readiness
Milburn argues that schools should explicitly develop the attributes young people need to navigate working life. These include:
- Communication.
- Collaboration.
- Creativity.
- Problem-solving.
- Timekeeping.
- Responding to feedback.
- Understanding workplace rights and expectations.
- Knowing how to ask for help.
- Finding opportunities.
- Completing applications.
- Approaching interviews.
Work readiness should not be reduced to teaching students how to write a CV or behave in an interview. It is about developing the confidence, knowledge, habits and social skills required to participate successfully in adult life.
What this means for schools:
> Create an explicit employability and personal development framework which runs through the curriculum, enrichment and careers programme.
6. Strengthen careers education and guidance
Milburn wants careers education to become more universal and better connected to real labour-market opportunities.
He recommends:
- Better access to digital careers information.
- Greater use of AI-enabled careers tools.
- Local and national labour-market information.
- Information about progression routes and earnings.
- Enhanced face-to-face guidance for students at risk of becoming NEET.
- Greater involvement of parents at important decision points.
The emphasis is on helping young people understand not simply what jobs exist, but how they can access them.
What this means for schools:
> Careers education should begin much earlier, be embedded across subjects and be closely linked to local employment opportunities.
7. Hold schools accountable for what happens after students leave
Milburn argues that schools should be judged not simply on examination outcomes but also on whether students are ready for work and successfully progress into education, training, or employment.
He proposes two new measures to be introduced in 2028:
A Ready-for-Work Standard
- Measures individual pupils’ readiness for working life.
- Aggregates results to produce a school-level ready-for-work rate.
- Includes attention to gaps for disadvantaged pupils and those with SEND.
A strengthened destination outcome measure
- Examines where students go after leaving school.
- Considers whether they remain successfully engaged in education, training or employment.
- Adjusts for students’ starting points and the circumstances of the communities schools serve.
The intention is to give these measures parity of esteem with existing school performance measures. This could fundamentally change the way schools think about success. A school would increasingly be judged not just on what students achieve at 16, but on how successfully it prepares them for what comes next.
Want more advice on securing future success for every child? Why not read the book…?

Book 3 in the Equity in Education series…

Discover more buzzing free content at bee-online.uk






